
230
ENSI Erfahrungs- und Forschungsbericht 2011
Project Goals
The safety impacts of air ingress on nuclear fuel
elements at high temperature have been studied
for many years, in accident situations involving
failure of the reactor pressure vessel (RPV) lower
head, shutdown conditions with the upper head
removed [1] and with, or in spent fuel ponds after
accidental loss of coolant [2]. The presence of air
can lead to accelerated oxidation of the Zircaloy
cladding compared with that in steam, owing to
the faster kinetics, while the 85 % higher heat of
reaction drives this process further. Air ingress is
typically associated with poor heat transfer; the
combined effect of these factors can give rise to an
increased rate of core degradation. Furthermore,
the exposure of uranium dioxide to air at high tem-
peratures can lead to increased release of some fis-
sion products [3]. The situation is kept under con-
tinual review, with experimental and modelling
studies performed, notably within the European
Union Framework SARNET project [4], and the In-
ternational Source Term Programme (ISTP) [5], in
which PSI takes part.
The MELCOR code is the major tool in use in Swit-
zerland for analysis of severe accidents in light
water reactors, from initiating events through to
potential release of radionuclide fission products
to the environment. Version 1.8.6 [6] is now es-
tablished as the current production version while
MELCOR 2.1 is still undergoing assessment. Use
of MELCOR is backed-up by SCDAP-based codes
[7], [8], for more detailed treatment of thermal
hydraulics and core degradation. The air ingress
model is being implemented in both MELCOR and
SCDAP/Sim.
The present three-year project running from 2009
to 2012 comprises two complementary activities
being pursued in tandem. The first of these is a
continuation of the previous PSI-ENSI collabora-
tion [9]. The model is being implemented in MEL-
COR to enable simulation of integral experiments
and plant or spent fuel transients. In the second
activity PSI is participating in the OECD Sandia Fuel
Project (SFP) [10], which will provide a prototypic
dataset under large scale fuel pond loss of cool-
ant conditions for validation of MELCOR code and
air oxidation models. The intended result is an im-
proved tool for plant and fuel pond simulation to
support PSA investigations and source term stud-
ies.
Work Carried Out
and Results Obtained
This section is divided into two parts. The first
presents a status of modelling activities during
the first year of the present PSI-ENSI collabora-
tion [11], which concentrate mostly on its imple-
mentation in MELCOR and SCDAP/Sim, the lat-
ter to enable validation against PARAMETER-SF4,
an air ingress experiment. The second part pres-
ents an overview of the SFP project, the experi-
ments planned therein and the sought-for results.
An indication is given of further work that could
be carried out, including a possible generalisa-
tion of the model to advanced cladding materi-
als such as Zirlo
TM
and M5
TM
, that feature in cur-
rent new reactors.
Part 1: Air oxidation modelling
Review of state of knowledge
Experimental Activities
The last formal reviews of activities in the experi-
mental area was presented at ERMSAR2008 [12],
and TOPSAFE2008 [13]. The status of studies con-
tinuing since then has been regularly reported in
the present series of annual progress statements.
During the last year further separate effects exper-
iments have been performed at KIT [14], concen-
trating on nitriding of homogenised alpha-Zr(O).
The latest air ingress bundle transient experiment,
QUENCH-16, was performed in July 2011[15]. It
comprised a comparatively minor degree of pre-
Figure 1: Sample results of QUENCH-16, indicating the
main phases of the experiment, the thermal response
during air ingress and the oxidation excursion during
reflood.
Komentáře k této Příručce